The Catholic Company Reviews

The Catholic Company has an overall rating of 4.7 based on 26 reviews. Customer feedback on The Catholic Company is mixed: The Catholic Company reviewers highlight positive aspects like wide selection of religious items, quality products, excellent customer service, fast shipping, which strongly appeal to Catholic individuals, families seeking religious items, churches and religious organizations. However, The Catholic Company is often criticized for its higher prices than competitors, occasional stock issues, website navigation difficulties, limited international shipping options.

4.7/5.0

26 reviews

5 Stars

16

4 Stars

7

3 Stars

0

2 Stars

0

1 Star

0

All The Catholic Company Reviews (26)
ROWE
May 31, 2026
"Arrived Way Faster Than I Thought"
I swear this showed up quicker than anything I’ve ordered in my life. I expected to wait a bit, but nope — it was here super fast. Shipping was absolutely, no-question, ridiculously quick.
CharlesRuiz_96
May 27, 2026
"Clear updates and an easy ordering experience"
I had a really good experience ordering from Catholic Company. The email updates were actually helpful, and I always knew when my order shipped and when it was supposed to arrive. With some other places I’ve ordered from, I’m left checking tracking links and wondering what’s going on, but this was much smoother. Everything arrived just fine, and the whole process was simple and stress-free. I’d definitely order from them again...
james.Henry
May 20, 2026
"Super easy return and quick refund"
I accidentally ordered the wrong size, so I had to send it back. i was expecting the return to be a hassle, but it ended up being really straightforward. My refund came through faster than I thought it would, and when I reached out with a question, customer service answered it without making me feel like I was bothering them. To me, that kind of simple, no-stress support makes a big difference.
Allen_hebb83
May 19, 2026
"Easy payment, just a little slow to update"
I ordered from catholiccompany.com and the payment process was easy. I put in my card, it went through without any issues, and the receipt showed up in my email like it should. No weird errors, no declined message, no double charge, nothing like that. The only thing that threw me off a bit was the billing update took longer than I expected, so for a little while I wasn’t totally sure if the order had actually processed. I kept checking my email, then my account, then my bank app, just to make sure. In the end everything was fine, the payment went through, and there were no extra charges. Just a small delay, so I’d still say it was a smooth experience overall.
HESLOP
May 17, 2026
"Packed well, but could use a little more tape"
My order from Catholic Company arrived in good shape overall. I’ve ordered fragile items online before and had things show up cracked or poorly wrapped, so I was relieved to see everything inside was protected well and nothing was broken.

The box did have one corner that was a bit bent when it got to me, but thankfully the packaging inside held up. The only thing I noticed was that one of the flaps was starting to lift, so I think a little extra tape would make it feel more secure.

All in all, it was a good experience and my items made it safely. It wasn’t absolutely perfect, but based on this order, I’d still feel comfortable ordering from them again.
hello_richard025
May 10, 2026
"Really nice rosary"
I was in a calm, reflective mood when I opened this, and I was impressed. The rosary feels solid and well made, nicer than I expected for the price. I’m really happy with it.
hello_marguerite649
May 09, 2026
"I was feeling mentally drained..."
I was feeling mentally drained when I ordered, so I just wanted something simple and reasonably priced. Overall, the value was good and I found a few nice deals, but some items still felt a little pricey. Shipping was also a bit more than I expected, which made the total less of a bargain.
ToddKeast_00
May 02, 2026
"Exactly as described"
It was exactly as described, exactly. The description was right, and I got pretty much what I expected.
FINLEY
April 28, 2026
"Really good Catholic selection"
They has a really nice selection of Catholic items, like rosaries, books, medals, and little gifts. I found what I was looking for quickly, and I’d definitely shop here again
RichardSampson
April 17, 2026
"They got back to me quick"
Had a small issue with my order and support replied fast, they got it sorted out without much hassle
ILES
March 18, 2026
"Really helps me stay consistent with prayer"
I picked up a rosary and a prayer book from here, they’ve been a real help in my daily prayer routine. They make it easier for me to stay focused and consistent. I’m really glad I got them.
JohnPerez
February 24, 2026
"Backorder took a while, but they kept me in the loop"
My item ended up being on backorder, and I wasn’t sure how it was going to go at first. Waiting longer than expected is never fun, but they did send email updates along the way, which made a difference. It reminded me that sometimes good service isn’t about everything going perfectly, but about not being left wondering what’s happening. The item did arrive, and while I wish it had been faster, the communication was solid enough that I’d order from them again...
julie.Ross
February 14, 2026
"The shipping cost was fair, honestly… not..."
The shipping cost was fair, honestly… not one of those crazy fees you see on some other sites. I was happy with my order overall and I’d definitely buy from them again.
GudrunMcclelland
February 04, 2026
"Nice surprise for a bargain hunter"
As someone who always looks for a deal before checking out, I was happy to see some good discounts pop up. The promo codes actually helped me save a bit, which always feels like a win.
edwin1981
January 31, 2026
"Got my order issue handled quickly"
I had an issue with my order and wasn’t sure how much of a hassle it was going to be. Customer service got back to me quickly, explained what happened, and took care of it without making me jump through hoops. It was way easier than I expected, especially compared to some other places where you’re just... Anyway, I really appreciated the help and would order from Catholic Company again.
jeremy_Duggan84
January 30, 2026
"The name turned out just right"
I was a little worried about the personalization, but yeah, it came out exactly right. Like, no weird spelling mistakes or anything off with the name, so I was really happy with it
EliasHightower
January 28, 2026
"Good selection, just missed one item"
They had a good selection overall, and most of the stuff I wanted was available. One item ended up being out of stock, but support got back to me and basically said they were sorry and would restock it soon. Not a huge deal, just a little annoying.
CrystalPrice
January 27, 2026
"It arrived safely and looked great, actually, I..."
It arrived safely and looked great—actually, I was expecting maybe a little ding or something from shipping, but nope, no damage at all.
Virginia.koehn
January 26, 2026
"Checkout was simple"
Checkout was quick, honestly. I was kind of expecting something to pop up or slow me down, but nope, it just went through. Super easy, no issues, and then I was done before I even really thought about it...
william1972
January 19, 2026
"Actually feels Catholic, down to the little details"
This really felt Catholic in a way that didn’t come across as generic or watered down. I noticed the small things, the wording, the tone, even the way certain details were presented, and it all felt legit. It gave me the sense that someone actually understands the faith, not just the surface-level version of it

View More Reviews

Have a question about The Catholic Company?
catholiccompany

The Catholic Company Reviews

Coupons & Promo Codes

Customer Reviews

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.